Handcrafted from scratch with premium ingredients. Custom cakes, fresh cookies, pastries, and sweet treats for every occasion.
Made to Order
Every cake is baked fresh and decorated by hand. Tell us your vision, and we'll bring it to life.
$35-75
Custom-designed birthday cakes in your favorite flavors. From classic chocolate to creative themed designs for kids and adults alike.
Order NowCustom Quote
Elegant, multi-tiered wedding cakes crafted to match your vision. Schedule a tasting to find your perfect flavor and design.
Order Now$45-85
Graduations, anniversaries, baby showers, and more. Beautiful cakes that make every milestone sweeter.
Order Now$24-36
Gourmet cupcakes in a variety of flavors. Perfect for parties, office events, or when you just want to share something special.
Order NowSweet Treats
Beyond cakes, we offer a delicious selection of baked goods -- perfect for gifting, sharing, or treating yourself.
$12-18
Fresh-baked cookies in classic and seasonal flavors. Chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, peanut butter, and more.
$15/dozen
Rich, fudgy brownies made with real chocolate. Available plain, with walnuts, or topped with cream cheese swirl.
$18/dozen
Soft, pillowy cinnamon rolls with warm spices and cream cheese frosting. Best enjoyed fresh from the oven.
Varies
Rotating menu of seasonal treats -- pumpkin pies, holiday cookies, fruit tarts, and more depending on the season.
Simple & Easy
Reach out to discuss what you need. We'll help you choose flavors, sizes, and designs.
Everything is made from scratch with premium ingredients, baked fresh for your order date.
Convenient pickup in North Canton or delivery available for larger orders in the surrounding area.
What People Say
Kaylee and Diners Choice is absolutely amazing!! I always know I can count on Kaylee to have an amazing dinner or dessert! I texted Kaylee the night before, and by 1pm the next day I had handmade fresh desserts at my door! I 100% recommend Kaylee and Diners Choice!!
Natalie R.
Facebook Review
Highly recommend, great food!
Dell O.
Facebook Review
Chicken parm was awesome. Chicken was moist and sauce perfectly seasoned. Definitely recommending.
Ann S.
Facebook Review
Nothing better than waking up on a Saturday morning to a delicious home cooked breakfast. The sausage gravy & biscuits were delivered on time and hot! Amazing!! Highly recommend.
Lindsay S.
Facebook Review
Our order was delivered on time and was absolutely perfect! Food was still nice and warm ready to serve! She did an amazing job! Will be ordering from Diners Choice again!!! Thank you!
Josh S.
Facebook Review
Questions?
We recommend at least 1 week for custom cakes and 2-4 weeks for wedding cakes or elaborate designs. Cookies, brownies, and other baked goods typically need 48-72 hours notice. Rush orders may be possible - just ask!
We offer vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, carrot, lemon, strawberry, marble, and seasonal flavors like salted caramel and cookies & cream. Custom flavor requests are always welcome! We also offer tastings for wedding cake orders.
We can accommodate many dietary needs including gluten-free and egg-free options. Please let us know about any allergies or restrictions when ordering so we can best serve you. Fully vegan cakes are available upon request.
Yes! We offer delivery within the North Canton and surrounding areas for an additional fee based on distance. This ensures your cake arrives safely and in perfect condition. Pickup is always available at no extra charge.
Call or text us to place your order. We'd love to bake something special for you!
Most orders ready within 1-2 weeks — rush orders welcome!